Water Cooled R9 290 vs GTX 780 Showdown
Linus Tech Tips
·Linus Tech Tips
·2014-05-07
·
1,257 words · ~6 min read
0:06
by and unlocked Intel fourth gen core i7 or core i5 processor and get a free copy
0:10
of Rome 2 Total War click now to learn more the AMD Radeon r9290 when it
0:16
launched to turn the graphics card Market pretty much on its ear by
0:19
delivering performance competitive with the then $700 plus gtx780 at
0:26
$400 there were some issues however power tune is AMD's technology that
0:31
balances power consumption clock speed temperature and fan speed so while the
0:37
card is advertised to run it up to 947
0:41
MHz it and its Big Brother the 290x often runs into thermal limits causing
0:47
clock speeds and voltage to scale down so they don't actually run at the speeds
0:51
on the Box in games this throttling Behavior could be blamed on a couple of
0:55
things one of them is the high heat output of the Hawaii GPU with its mass
1:00
6 billion transistors the other is the lackluster reference cooler with its
1:04
loud fan that forces end users to choose
1:07
between hairdryer like noise or throttled performance now whatever you
1:12
want to blame it on there were a few things that were very clear number one
1:15
is that the r9290 already performed very
1:18
well against the GTX 780 which prompted NVIDIA to drop prices only down to 500
1:23
mind you but it was a drop number two is that we won't have a clear idea of what
1:27
the card is truly capable of until until we get better coolers in the form of
1:31
twin frozer or direct cu2 class coolers from guys like MSI and ASUS even with
1:37
custom a cooling though we'd have no way to know for sure whether any thermal
1:42
throttling was occurring we've observed both good and bad things about NVIDIA's
1:46
GPU Boost 2.0 which is similar to AMD's power tune a good thing about it is that
1:51
unlike AMD they provide a base clock so
1:54
you'll have a reference point for the minimum performance you'll be getting if
1:57
you buy the card one bad thing we've noticed however is that while GPU Boost
2:01
2.0 provides enduser customization and
2:05
allows you to change your thermal limit manually for example from 80° to 95° it
2:11
seems to be actually just doing whatever it wants in the background
2:15
so yeah you can change it but it's just
2:18
throttling anyway so we wanted to remove all possibility of thermal throttling
2:23
and liquid cool the cards fortunately we
2:26
contacted klance who hooked us up not only with a water block that fits on
2:30
either the R9 290 or the 290x you can check the link in the video description
2:34
for pricing and availability of the gear we used in this video but also a GTX 780
2:40
block a pump a reservoir and some awesome awesome quick disconnect
2:44
fittings that let us do very fast graphics card swaps on our first ever
2:49
liquid cooled test bench in fact guys I just disconnected a tube here that's
2:53
completely full of water and we got no leakage whatsoever all right moving on
2:57
to the test we used the Maximus 5 formul with a 3770k at 3.9 GHz 8 gigs of DDR3
3:03
memory at 1600 MHz and a PC power and cooling 1200 W power supply as always
3:09
our graphics cards were overclocked as high as they could go on both air and
3:15
water and we used two separate liquid cooling Loops for the CPU and for the
3:20
graphics card so we could isolate the heat generated by the GPU so we could
3:23
remove variables when evaluating them in terms of their thermal performance if
3:27
you guys want to see the clock speeds we were running at on the graphics cards
3:30
there will be a link to our chart in the video description below our results
3:34
surprised us a lot uh we were like everyone on the entire internet
3:38
expecting the r9290 to overclock like a beast and destroy the 780 out of which
3:44
we were expecting only a mild performance Improvement now because we
3:48
traditionally set our 780 to 95° on the
3:52
thermal limit for an apples to Apple's comparison against AMD cards and it only
3:56
ever runs at 80° we assumed that there was no additional head room to unlock
4:00
with better cooling because we were never hitting our userdefined thermal
4:04
limits but it turns out that for liquid
4:07
cooling enthusiasts NVIDIA's monkey business with the user adjustable
4:12
thermal limits turns into some pretty good performance gains for that card
4:15
when it's running underwater as well so first up is thermal performance both
4:20
cards ran between 35 to 45° C underload
4:23
with the 780 being closer to 35 and the 290 being closer to 45 uh when it comes
4:29
to gaming performance we only really tested a couple games because what we
4:32
were looking for in this video was performance scaling from air to water so
4:37
a huge library of games wasn't really necessary what we found is that the max
4:41
overclocked performance of the GTX 780 improved by just under 10% and the max
4:47
overclock performance of the r9290 improved by about 7% that means that
4:52
basically when you're out there shopping and deciding between these two cards
4:56
with the intention of going water you can basically look add any performance
5:00
comparison chart and factor in another 5 to 10% for each when you're doing your
5:05
value analysis on the subject of value
5:08
and performance this video is a great example of why I don't talk about
5:12
pricing for products in my videos the r9290 launched at $400 which would have
5:17
made it a clear winner against the $500
5:20
gtx780 in this particular Showdown but
5:24
it now costs $500 too making it exactly the same price but with higher power
5:29
consumption and higher heat output so for the gamers out there the GTX 780
5:34
gets the nod from me at the moment but
5:37
there are things other than games and amds cards are well known to perform
5:41
incredibly well against their NVIDIA counterparts in some Computer
5:45
Applications one example of which being cryptocurrency Mining and folks are
5:50
buying up AMD graphics cards by the truckload for Bitcoin and Litecoin
5:55
Mining and that's been causing some serious changes to the retail pricing as
5:59
I outlined before so ultimately it'll be up to you the viewer to look at the
6:03
performance numbers then check out the values that we're showing you in terms
6:07
of what you can expect when overclocking then check out the links to the cards in
6:10
the video description and do the value calculation for yourself if you're
6:14
curious guys you can see the overclocked values for our graphics cards in the
6:17
Google Doc Linked In the video description remember that overclocking
6:20
is always a crapshoot and you may get a card that overclocks better than ours
6:24
you may get one that overclocks worse than ours and there's no guarantee for
6:28
any of that stuff so anyway guys I hope you enjoyed this video on the removal of
6:32
thermal limits from the r9290 and the gtx780 let us know in the comments if
6:37
the results surprised you or if they were what you expected like the video if
6:42
you liked it dislike it if you disliked it and not as always wow it's doing
6:46
really good up till there as always don't forget to subscribe to lonus Tech
6:49
tips