iSwitched to Android Blog Day 30 of my 30 Day Challenge Linus Tech Tips
Linus Tech Tips
·Linus Tech Tips
·2013-05-07
·
3,362 words · ~16 min read
0:00
Welcome to day 30 of my I switch to Android blog. I realized I haven't
0:03
actually done as many updates as I did when I did my switch to Windows Phone 8.
0:08
And there's a very good reason for this. So, I went from iOS to Windows Phone 8,
0:12
back to iOS, and now to Android. And the reason I haven't really had much to say
0:16
is I haven't really thought of anything to complain about. And in my first two
0:19
videos, I really did cover most of what I thought was great about the platform
0:23
as well as about the HTC1 in particular.
0:27
So, I've been kind of sitting here thinking, what can I possibly say other
0:31
than I'm switching to Android and this will likely be my permanent home for the
0:36
foreseeable future. Now, with that said, there are some interesting competitors
0:40
in the Android space. This right here is the Galaxy S4. So, I'm going to treat
0:44
this video as my final thoughts on Android in general, as well as some of
0:48
the observations I've made about the HTC1 while using it for 30 days and a
0:53
little bit of comparison between the One and the S4, which I've now had my hands
0:56
on for about 10 days. So, we'll start with the HTC1. Um, if I had to complain
1:02
about something in Sense 5.0, it's the fact or 55 plus or whatever they're
1:06
calling it now. Uh, it would be the inelegant implementation of the stock
1:10
music player. So, the stock music player is media music. The stock music player
1:15
is well integrated with the OS, but the navigation isn't that great. And what I
1:22
discovered myself doing uh because it doesn't have a built-in EQ is I found
1:26
myself uh trying to find an alternative music player. So, the ones that I tried
1:30
were whoops, excuse me, Rocket Player as well as um Win Amp. So, these have the
1:37
advantages of EQ settings, but they don't integrate with the Sense 5.0
1:44
UI as well as the stock one does. So, for example, with the stock one, I can
1:49
have a lock screen that has a music player. Whereas with the other ones, I
1:54
can't have it on the lock screen, but I can implement it here. But even their
1:58
their integrations here aren't that great, and they have some strange behaviors. Like for example, um if I
2:03
plug in my headphones right now, you're going to see that it's just going to
2:07
start playing music even though I don't necessarily want it to do that. Um give
2:12
it a sec. Give it a sec. Yeah, it'll probably start doing that. See, there
2:15
you go. So, I have to actually tell it to go away every time I plug something
2:19
into the top of the device. So, I wish there was one that was as well integrated as the stock one, but sounded
2:24
a little better and had better navigation. Um, the market, I wish it kind of had a
2:29
convenient favorites list of apps. And this one right here, app backup and
2:33
restore, is really cool. So, what it does is it just creates a file that you
2:37
dump onto your computer. And then you copy that into the uh into the folder on
2:42
another phone. And what happens is as soon as you launch it, you can restore
2:46
and it'll install all the apps that you had installed on the device. So, I used
2:49
this when I went from using the HTC1
2:52
only to using the Galaxy S4 as well because it allowed me to just load my
2:57
entire app load out onto it. Now, I remember in the tablet version of Android on Honeycomb in the market, you
3:02
were able to just see all of the apps that you downloaded before and I wasn't able to find that, but that doesn't mean
3:07
it's not there. And I found this was a little bit inelegant. So, I was I got
3:11
prompted by every app. Are you sure? Yes. Are you sure? Do you agree? Yes.
3:14
Yes. So, it took it took a long time to install all the apps even though I had
3:18
the full list. So, um that's something that I that I wish Android had because
3:22
with iOS it's simple. You back up your phone, you restore your phone, and
3:26
everything's exactly the way you left it. I did find the People app a little
3:29
bit confusing. So, I'm I still am not really using the stock Android desktop,
3:33
and I'm not using Blink Feed. I'm just using this list right here, which is
3:36
more like Gingerbread. So, I did find the People app Oh, I should probably turn that H. Yeah, nothing there that
3:41
matters. I did find the people app a little bit confusing. a lot of the the
3:45
links that it suggested weren't right and it didn't pick up on a lot of the
3:49
links that I ended up setting up manually. But once I did set them all up
3:52
manually, it's it's great except that it
3:56
doesn't really allow me to pick. Do I want to pull that person's Facebook
3:59
picture? Do I want to use my own picture that I took of them so that I know who
4:05
I'm talking to because not everyone uses a picture of themselves for Facebook.
4:08
So, for example, when my wife calls, it's a picture of my baby because that's
4:11
what she uses for her Facebook picture. if I can't figure out how to change it.
4:15
Uh, multitasking is still a highlight of the platform for me. I love this. I do
4:20
not miss the hardware button. In fact, going to the S4, which is more like the
4:25
button loadout that I'm used to, where you've got your context menu button
4:29
here, you've got your hard home button here, and then your soft back button
4:33
here. This is more like what I was used to with Android, but I didn't miss it at
4:37
all with the HTC1. I found that back,
4:41
home, and then multitask was really all I needed because that that context
4:46
button has been replaced with these dots up here. And I actually find it a little
4:49
bit easier to press. So, I mean, when I'm holding the device, I hold it like this. So, when I'm going to go back, I
4:54
can reach back. Okay, that's fine. It's a little bit of a stretch, but I don't go back as much as I might want to
4:59
access context because that's your your new tab, your bookmarks, all all those
5:03
kinds of things, which I actually like having on the right versus having on the
5:07
bottom left like that. So, yeah, I thought it was great. Uh, the camera is
5:10
still awesome on the HTC1. I know I've talked about this before. I I played
5:15
around with Zoe's or Zoies, which are those sort of 3 4 secondond clips that
5:19
you take and then you can take some pictures during it. I used them a little bit at first, but then I really found
5:24
myself not really bothering with it and just using video a lot more because it's
5:27
so quick. You can go from you can go
5:31
from lock screen to
5:34
recording a video in that long. And so what I just found myself doing is if I
5:38
wanted a 4- second video clip, well, I'm gonna take a four-se secondond video clip. That's what I'll do. So the the
5:42
Zoies didn't really uh didn't really matter that much to me, but I do think
5:46
they're a better implementation than Samsung's thing with the still photo and
5:49
the audio recording that goes with it. I' I'd rather have the video and then I
5:53
can capture a few still photos at the same time. Um I do on the other hand
5:57
find myself watching highlight reels of previous days. It is so cool. Uh, if we
6:02
go into my photos, I'm just going to pick a random day, such as, for example,
6:06
this day. I think we were we did a video shoot. Um,
6:11
so let's just see what it comes up with on its own. So, here's me dressing up the cat. Here's our actor as well as our
6:16
film crew. Here's me and Diesel crammed into the back. It's a really cool way to
6:20
look back at a day of of events.
6:26
So, here's we did some behindthe-scenes footage of this particular shoot. So
6:30
that's what a lot of it is. But yeah, it's just it's a it's just really cool.
6:37
So yeah, I do find myself using this, but not not Zoe's at all. Uh the feeling
6:42
of solidity with this phone is outstanding. It's really unlike any
6:46
other device other than an Apple device that I've ever seen. So I want you to watch the pressure my thumbs are
6:51
exerting on the phone here.
6:54
As hard as I might press, I can't get the phone to flex, which is I mean, I
7:00
kind of took it for granted a little bit going from iOS to this phone, going from
7:04
an iPhone 4, which is also a very solid device, to this one. I was like, "Oh, yeah, well, whatever. No devices flex.
7:08
Of course, they do." Uh, this is the Galaxy S4, and with this one, you can
7:12
probably see that bend, particularly on
7:15
my right thumb. I'm putting about the same amount of pressure on it. Is the S4
7:19
a solidly built device? You know what? Probably. It's better than the S3. It
7:23
feels better to hold than the S3 with the squared corners, but it without the
7:27
metal backing, which Samsung sacrifices in order to get things like the optional
7:32
wireless charging back cover as well as being able to integrate your cover, like
7:37
the front case cover with the back cover and have it all be one piece in order to
7:41
give you that micro SD upgrade as well as the removable battery. These are the
7:45
sacrifices Samsung has made in order to um to bring you those those
7:49
functionalities. But I I like the
7:52
feeling of this and the honestly the finish on the aluminum is one of the best ones I've encountered in spite of
7:57
the fact that it's a phone. It's still immaculate. Most br even brushed or
8:01
anodized aluminum surfaces. Every time you put them down on something solid
8:05
like a table, you put them on a table and they they slide a little bit, you go, "Oh no, I just scratched it. I'm
8:11
sure I just scratched it." No, not with the one. I really didn't get that
8:15
impression at all. Um she does get hot
8:18
when she's under load. My hand got a bit sweaty the other day when I was sitting
8:22
in the car with navigation running in the background and I was watching a
8:25
video on it. So, navigation was running so that the driver could hear um the
8:29
navigation things, but I was sitting watching a video. She got toasty. Whenever you uh whenever you share your
8:35
wireless network with people, it does get quite toasty. But the flip side of
8:38
that is at least it has the aluminum backing to help dissipate the heat. So,
8:42
yeah, it's more hot to my hand, but that probably means my processors are
8:45
actually running cooler. Um,
8:49
you know what? Actually, here something I should have mentioned when I said I didn't miss the uh the hard button here
8:53
is Windows phone probably helped a lot as a buffer to help me break that habit
8:57
because I mean honestly the search button is pretty much useless. I never
9:01
used it. The Windows button is good and the back button is good. So essentially
9:05
I had two buttons. I had home and back which D home and back. So, it's quite
9:10
possible that that was part of the learning experience there as well because I went from a platform with just
9:14
a home button to a platform with a home button, a useless button, and a back
9:18
button to this. And I haven't really used the S4 super extensively yet. HTC,
9:25
actually, there's some leaked pictures that the HTC1 in China is going to have
9:28
this back piece removable with a micro SD slot. You know what? I already find
9:32
myself wishing I had a micro SD slot. My 16 gig iPhone, never used the whole
9:36
thing. Never found that to be a problem. This is 32 gigs. I've already almost
9:40
filled it. And a big part of the reason for that is I'm shooting so much HD
9:44
video with it, so much 1080p video that I find myself filling it. Also, it's so
9:49
much of a bigger screen. It's great for content. So, when I don't take something
9:52
like a Seagate Wireless Plus out with me, um, it's nice to be able to load
9:56
some videos on here. And with wireless AC, I can transfer things to myself very
10:01
quickly. And, and there's all these good things about it that really mean I would
10:04
love to be able to throw a 64 gig micro SD in there. So, I I wish HTC would
10:09
reconsider and do an HTC1 plus or something for other regions where they
10:13
implement the micro SD, but I really don't see it happening. Uh, widgets are
10:18
cool, but honestly, I um as a user who
10:21
who sees pretty well and is used to the iOS experience and has this great
10:26
multitasking interface where I can see the last nine things that I've done, I
10:30
didn't find myself really using any of them. It comes with a lot of stock
10:33
widgets that you can uh that you can add just by going down here and you can add
10:37
a calendar and bookmarks and FM radio
10:40
and all that kind of cool. I just didn't find myself using it. I prefer the
10:45
density of this interface with folders
10:48
where I can take put almost everything I need and just put it here on one page.
10:54
Um, and I'll just open up the app or
10:57
instead of going back to the home screen. So, you know, like home screen, home screen to get back to the Google
11:02
one, going like this to find my appropriate widget. If I just go like
11:05
this, most of the things that I use a lot of the time, like my Gmail, my
11:09
calendar, are within the last nine things that I've used. So, there's very
11:12
few situations where I would need a widget in order to make it quicker for
11:15
me to access it. So, there you go. Oh.
11:18
Oh, and like compared to widgets, I'd much rather have things implemented into
11:22
the drop- down menu here, like my power toggles. I just realized I had my Wi-Fi
11:26
off. This I use all the time, and this
11:29
is a very natural way for me to access it compared to click, click, left, left,
11:34
right, right, or whatever else I happen to be doing. Try that one. So, this is
11:39
something iOS users, I'm sure, will appreciate is how simple it is to set a
11:44
song as your ringtone on Android. I'm sure every other platform has been
11:47
taking this for granted for ever, but uh
11:51
as a longtime iOS user, I was like, really? I just like long click it and
11:54
then set to be my ringtone. Holy crap,
11:58
that's the easiest thing ever. So, that was a really neat thing to uh to run
12:02
into. And I think at the end of the day, here's what it comes down to. Um after
12:07
my 30-day trial, yes, I'm switching to Android. I'm still going to be open to
12:11
trying new platforms such as Ubuntu Phone or BlackBerry. Actually, there's a
12:15
Blackberry in the mail. So, I might uh I might have to kind of cheat on my new my
12:20
new love Android very very soon. Skype integration was much better than Windows
12:24
Phone. Uh similar to iOS, so that's something that I realize I haven't
12:27
talked about yet. But there you go, guys. Thanks for coming along for the
12:31
ride. Um Oh, right. I just realized I
12:34
never really did any of the talking about Galaxy S4 other than the
12:38
ruggedness of it. So, I think the thing that I find most strikingly different
12:42
between TouchWiz and Sense is that
12:46
TouchWiz feels very um very bubbly, very
12:49
happy. You know, it's all super bright colors and sort of big big friendly
12:54
icons and sort of easy easy to uh easy
12:58
to touch. Whereas Sense feels more um a
13:01
little bit more more elegant, but maybe not as uh maybe not as easy to use. Like
13:07
it's really cool the way TouchWiz already has this this implemented so you
13:11
can switch things on and off. I think the easy mode on TouchWiz makes it the
13:15
kind of thing where here I'm going to see if I can find uh see if I can find
13:19
easy mode. I was playing around with it before and it's the kind of thing where
13:23
I'd go, okay, yeah, I'm going to get an HTC1, but if I was going to get a phone
13:27
for my mom, then I would just give her
13:30
the S4 because yeah, I can't find it
13:34
right now. Anyway, so easy mode just basically consolidates Android down to
13:38
like a few buttons. Um, S translates really cool. Um, I did find that smart
13:44
stay worked for me and was very helpful. The HTC1 is sort of just like every
13:48
other phone where if you're reading something for a long time, um, it'll dim
13:52
and it'll eventually turn off, whereas that doesn't happen with the Samsung
13:56
phone. I personally didn't find the hovering above the screen and it
14:00
detecting things very helpful at all in things like the browser. Um, it would
14:04
just be zoomed in looking at stuff that I'm I'm just trying to move my finger
14:08
closer to the screen. I just went, "No, just let me touch the touchcreen and I'm good with that." Um, what were some of
14:14
the other things that I found myself I found myself turning off the um
14:20
um yeah, those ones right away. NFC is good. Um, gesturing was kind of cool,
14:26
but it's a very unnatural thing for me. Like for example, gesture gesturing to
14:30
take a call. I was like, "Oh, well, you just do it like this, right?" That
14:34
didn't work. And it wasn't just one. So, you have to go back and forth kind of
14:38
slow. And I'm looking at it going, "Okay, so if I was driving and I had it
14:41
in a cradle or something like that, yeah, that's very practical. But in
14:44
everyday use, it's probably not the kind of thing that I would use unless I
14:48
really wanted to use all the features that came with my new phone. So, thank
14:52
you for checking this out. Don't forget to subscribe to Linus Tech Tips for more unboxings, reviews, and other computer
14:56
videos. And uh the baby decided to join us because he woke up when we were
15:00
filming and nobody was there to go get him. Sorry, sweetie. So there you go.