Meccanoid G15 KS - A box of empty promises
Linus Tech Tips
·Linus Tech Tips
·2016-05-06
·
2,122 words · ~10 min read
0:00
Designed for kids aged 10 and up, the Mechenoid is both a toy and a robotics
0:04
kit. It's being touted as a personal robot best friend. They say you can
0:09
build anything and that programming is easy and innovative. They say your kid
0:13
will learn the core values of science, technology, engineering, and
0:17
mathematics. And you might think from all the positive reviews that the
0:20
Mechoid is great, but let me tell you something. The Mechonoid is a terrible
0:25
disappointment. It's an offensively bad box of empty promises. And all those
0:31
positive reviews are only looking at the Mechenoid at a superficial level. It's
0:35
going to be pretty interesting for me to be the sole voice of disscent on this
0:38
one. So, let's get into it, shall we?
0:49
I by Powers Revolt 2 has been redesigned from the ground up to utilize its small
0:54
form factor to hold the power you need to game with confidence. Check out their
0:57
link in the video description to learn more. Let me give you my thesis
1:01
statement right off the top. The Mechenoid is a robotics building
1:04
platform in name only because in reality
1:08
everything that makes a robotics kit good has been sacrificed and compromised
1:12
to blindly serve a singular objective to make this thing as cute as possible so
1:17
that it will sell. As a result, the pieces are misshapen, the instructions
1:22
are a mess, the assembly process is tedious, the programming options are
1:26
laughably simplistic, and the price tag is a bloated $400. Opening up the box
1:31
for the Mechenoid G15 KS, we see the
1:35
1,188 pieces, of which 961 are actually just nuts and bolts,
1:41
leaving 245 plastic pieces that actually comprise the robot itself. Now,
1:46
traditional mechano mechano macano potato
1:50
potato pieces are actually made out of metal, but the mechonoid pieces are
1:55
plastic. I'm guessing because a fully metal robot of this size would just be
1:59
absurdly expensive to produce. Of course, you could just make it smaller,
2:04
but then it wouldn't have the cool factor that they seem to be banking on.
2:07
What makes these pieces truly awful is not the fact that they're made out of
2:11
plastic, but the fact that they are such enormous, weird, and specialized shapes.
2:17
You see, traditional Macano pieces are modular and simple, allowing the builder
2:22
to be creative with them. But pretty much everything in the
2:26
GK15S's box was specifically designed to
2:29
build one robot. Technically, you can
2:33
build anything you like, but the pieces poor design makes this enormously
2:37
difficult. There aren't nearly enough attachment holes to use, and the few
2:41
that there are are not always positioned logically. There are also these random
2:45
studs that poke out and completely get in the way, making many configurations
2:49
impossible. The studs don't even serve to hold stuff together. They just simply
2:53
prevent pieces from sliding around while you attach them with the nuts and bolts.
2:58
I mean, what on earth am I supposed to do with this or this or this? They
3:03
seriously couldn't break these up into smaller, more constituent parts with
3:07
mounting points at predictable intervals. The only positive feature of
3:11
these pieces is that many of them have square indentations designed to hold the
3:15
nuts in place for when you're bolting everything together during assembly. So,
3:19
let's talk about that, shall we? Even though the designers decided to abandon
3:23
the triedand-true metal pieces that Macano is so well known for, they still
3:28
decided to keep the traditional nut andbolt attachment system, something
3:33
that people already complain about. Perhaps this was done to maintain
3:37
compatibility with the traditional metal pieces. But no self-respecting builder
3:42
is going to go anywhere near these plastic atrocities. So, frankly, I don't
3:46
see the point. Surely, there must be a simpler way for kids to quickly attach
3:51
these pieces together. Some kind of pin system that snaps in place, perhaps.
3:56
Nope. Instead, your 10-year-old will be stuck assembling this oversized
4:00
monstrosity for hours and hours of just screwing together pieces using these
4:04
tiny nuts and bolts, all 961 of them.
4:08
The entire process took me eight tedious hours. And unlike building something out
4:13
of Lego, I did not find it interesting or enjoyable. And that's partly due to
4:18
the dreadful instructions, which are so bad for so many reasons. Often they'll
4:23
combine several steps into one, which greatly increases the chance of doing
4:27
something wrong. Plus, there's almost never an image that shows what a fully
4:31
assembled step is supposed to look like. And you can't just look at the next step
4:35
for that because the model on the page underos constant changes in orientation.
4:40
Also, sometimes you have to use a slightly different nut or bolt, but
4:44
because they're all the same color, it's not immediately obvious. I hope you
4:48
didn't accidentally mix any of these bolts together. Even while paying very
4:51
close attention, I still made several mistakes, which can take quite a while
4:55
to realize and even longer to fix because it usually involves
4:59
disassembling some correct parts so that you can get to the incorrect parts. But
5:03
ladies and gentlemen, the disappointment doesn't stop there. With everything
5:07
finally attached and plugged in correctly, the Mechenoid runs through a
5:11
startup diagnostic routine, asks for your name, and enters the main menu. You
5:16
have to use voice commands to navigate the menus, which kind of feels like I'm
5:20
on the phone with my cell phone provider. Control section of the command
5:23
card or say list commands to hear all
5:27
commands. If you are still having trouble, please go to www. The voice
5:32
recognition seems to work well enough, but you do have to repeat yourself
5:36
sometimes, and you also have to wait for the mechanoid to stop talking before it
5:40
will listen for your commands, which can take a while. Here's a list of all the
5:44
mechonoids menu commands. It can tell jokes and tell you what time it is,
5:48
which is exactly as exciting as it sounds. Walk with me seems to work fine,
5:52
but doesn't look like it can move backwards in this mode. Shake hands and
5:56
high-five work pretty much just as you would expect them to. The motion control
6:01
commands also seem to work fine. It all
6:04
works. It's just not really that interesting. Forward.
6:10
Now, the website lists three innovative ways to program. So, let's take a look
6:15
at that. The first one, LIM, or learned intelligent movement, allows you to
6:20
physically move the robot's arms around, which can be recorded and replayed along
6:24
with your voice. I have to admit, I did have some fun with this one. No. No
6:30
disassemble. You can then save this to the LIM library and recall it later. No
6:36
disassemble. However, it's not nearly as precise as
6:40
the commercials would imply. Mechanoid is so easy to program. Nice robots run.
6:51
What a fail. It can't play the piano. Moving on to
6:56
Ragd Doll Avatar. You can use your smartphone to directly remote control
7:01
the movements of the mechonoid. This also works pretty well. You can even
7:05
change the colors of the LEDs if you really want to. And finally, motion
7:09
capture mode uses your smartphone's camera to record your movements, which
7:14
the Mechenoid will attempt to mimic. This one really does not work very well.
7:19
Sometimes the arms would flop around even while my own arms remained
7:23
completely stationary. And that's it. It's just three different ways you can
7:27
tell the robot to make noise and wave its arms around, which can be recorded
7:31
and replayed. I don't consider that to be programming. For the real
7:36
programming, you can download this Arduino library, but this only became
7:41
available quite recently, so it was obviously never really a priority. Well,
7:45
I guess if you understand C++, you can program the mechonoid any way you like.
7:50
But honestly, why would you want to? And tell me, what is the point of having
7:55
arms if the hands don't do anything? It
7:58
would be cool if the hands actually worked and the fingers could grasp
8:02
objects and pick stuff up, but they can't, which is boring. I guess you
8:07
could take it apart and build the dinosaur, you know, if you want another
8:10
10 tedious hours of bolting stuff together, but that sounds pretty boring,
8:15
too. Now, some of you may be thinking, "Hey, my kids enjoyed the Mechonoid, and
8:19
this guy isn't 10 years old, so why should his opinions matter?" Well, guess
8:23
what? I was a kid once, and I remember that the best toys were the ones with
8:28
great replay value. The toys I kept playing with and coming back to time and
8:33
time again. For me, this was Lego, Nintendo, Pokémon, Game Maker 5. I still
8:39
have all that stuff. And the other toys, they probably went to the trash or the
8:44
thrift store. Once assembled, there's so little you can do with the Mechenoid
8:48
that I don't see how it's going to maintain the interest of most children
8:51
beyond, I don't know, a week or two. And
8:55
after that, I predict the novelty will wear off and it'll be pushed into a
8:58
corner and never played with again. The mechanoid is so terrible, in fact, that
9:03
it feels to me like some other company designed it and then just slapped the
9:07
McConnell label on top. Which is kind of funny because I wrote those words and
9:11
then later discovered that it's actually true. Yes, my friends, it turns out that
9:15
McConnell was acquired in 2013 by a
9:19
company called SpinMaster. Oh, it all
9:22
makes sense now. Spin Master are the ones to blame for this mess. Look at
9:27
this article. Apparently, their idea of a renaissance is to add a bunch of
9:30
cheap, cutesy, colorful crap into the Macano lineup. Okay. Okay. Spin Master,
9:36
I know you're watching, and I've got something to say to you. Macano has
9:39
existed for over a hundred years because they made good quality, longlasting,
9:45
interesting products. Please try to exercise some responsibility and
9:49
restraint so that you don't completely drive them into the ground with flashin
9:54
the pan products like the Mechenoid. And hey, I've got a toy idea for you. How
9:59
about a full metal McConnell robot with wheels, gears, axles, beams, LEDs,
10:05
several motors, and a full array of sensors? Give it a fully programmable
10:08
brain with remote control and give us instructions for building cool stuff.
10:12
And then price it competitively. Now, that's a great robotics kit that would
10:17
support STEM education. VEX Robotics figured this out, and so can you. And
10:22
now, let's see if I can sell this thing. Maybe I can trade it in for a better toy
10:26
at Toy Traers. That's like the big robot
10:29
guy. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, we don't want them at all, actually. You don't
10:33
want them at all? No, not at all. I have one here that I'm not really having any
10:38
luck selling. This one I actually sold when it was returned. So, try and get my
10:42
money back if I'm lucky on that. Right. Okay. Thanks a lot. Oh, you're welcome.
10:47
Yeah. Bye-bye. They won't even take it at toy traders.
10:54
If the Mechonoid was just an overly expensive toy, I wouldn't care. But
10:58
they're selling it as if it's a STEM educational robotics kit, and it's just
11:04
not. The Mechenoid completely fails to
11:07
deliver enough fun or educational value to justify its $400 price tag. Okay,
11:14
everyone. That's all that's all I have to say. Uh I'm just I'm still I'm so
11:19
shocked at all the positive reviews for this thing. Do you think I'm missing
11:23
something? Am I wrong? Leave a comment below with your thoughts. And did you
11:27
play with traditional mechano growing up? What did you think of it? Leave a
11:31
comment about that, too. And go ahead and slap a like on this video or a
11:35
dislike. Get subscribed or don't. Whatever. Check out our forums. Buy a
11:40
t-shirt. I promise none of them cost $400. And check out my review of the VEX
11:44
IQ Super Kit if you want to see what a proper robotics kit looks like. And
11:49
hopefully I'll have a review of the Mindstorms EV3 coming soon as well. See
11:53
you next time.