Bang for the Buck Z97 Motherboard Showdown Part 3 - UEFI (BIOS) Experience & Usability
Linus Tech Tips
·Linus Tech Tips
·2015-05-07
·
2,496 words · ~12 min read
0:00
welcome to the third installment of the $1 100ish doll z97 motherboard Showdown
0:05
this video got bumped back many times from CES to getting sick twice and the
0:10
GTX 960 launch Etc but enough with
0:14
excuses The Show Must Go On as with the previous two videos we will be exploring
0:18
the world of affordable motherboards instead of top tier motherboards which
0:21
are expensive and don't really impact
0:25
performance we are doing this because we want to explore the pros and cons and
0:30
trade-offs of boards people are actually
0:33
buying in this video we will be covering the UEFI BIOS experience of each board
0:39
things like USB drive uh peripherals RAM
0:42
compatibility all that kind of stuff and other things just the usability of the
0:47
motherboard also stay subscribed for part four where we will be covering the
0:50
finished system experience and the final conclusion of this whole series
1:01
cooler Masters case mod World Series is your opportunity to show off your
1:05
modding skills and win great prizes entries Clos February 7th 2015 click now
1:10
to learn more I was delightfully surprised when each board not only
1:14
worked with every keyboard and mouse but also was able to post with XMP for each
1:18
RAM kit what was expected and yet no
1:22
less incredibly frustrating however was the issues that I encountered with flash
1:27
drive compatibility there are a few things more frustrating than being stuck
1:31
with a board that needs a ufi BIOS update no optical drive and a flash
1:36
drive that won't detect but that being
1:39
said this may not be that big of an issue as many of you probably have a few
1:44
old flash drives laying around which tend to work a lot more often but
1:48
whether it's during an update or something else what if your ufi BIOS
1:53
gets corrupted how will you recover well luckily the Gigabyte board comes with
1:57
dual UEFI BIOS support so can easily just switch from your corrupted one to a
2:02
fresh new one uh in basically no time but also noteworthy is that the ASUS
2:07
board and the ASRock board have swappable BIOS chips which may be a
2:12
little annoying as you would need to contact a manufacturer for a replacement
2:16
but at least it gives you the option of repairing your board while MSI includes
2:21
no actual other safeguards now onto what
2:24
I know a lot of you have been actually waiting for the actual usability of the
2:28
UEFI BIOS but a few disclaimers must be
2:31
made here first each one of these UEFI BIOS setups could have easily taken an
2:35
entire video dedicated to them naturally
2:38
I will be focusing on what makes each of these experiences unique Instead at
2:43
their core they all provide the same general functionality you can review
2:47
core system specs change your boot device set up a password for system boot
2:52
Etc as there is virtually no difference in the overclocking capabilities due to
2:56
Intel moving more and more things onto
2:59
the chip every time this leaves ease of use quirks and standout features as the
3:05
focus of this segment another important disclaimer is that many things that I
3:10
talk about will be my opinion but for
3:13
your convenience I will be including as much footage of each ufi BIOS as
3:17
possible so you can come to your own conclusions we'll start with a Seuss the
3:22
easy mode start page is amazing to be honest before writing this review I
3:27
would always skip right over the easy mode and and go into Advance mode right
3:31
away but once I actually looked at it it has almost everything an average user
3:36
will need to access quickly system information RAM SATA configuration easy
3:41
tuning boot priority and a boot menu for overriding boot order if you need to
3:45
oneoff boot to something like say a flash drive XMP settings irst on or off
3:51
and a dedicated fan control setting which includes four different profiles
3:56
manual control which is fantastic in granularity of seeming 1% a pwm or DC
4:02
switch and a quick view for what fans are plugged in and their current status
4:07
along with various helpful keyboard shortcuts clearly labeled along the
4:10
bottom moving on to advanced mode we have all the detailed fine-tuning
4:15
options that you would expect out of an advanced mode and all of these options
4:19
are under sensible headers along with a detailed hardware monitor nicely and
4:23
permanently fixed on the right hand side the hot keys are no longer against the
4:27
bottom like they were in Easy Mode but you you can find a handy list available
4:31
in the top right hand corner which will lay them all out for you there's also a
4:35
favorite section which you can add things to so if you know you're going to
4:38
commonly be tweaking something you can add it there and there's also the nice
4:41
additional functionality of an inbios notepad if you need to leave reminders
4:46
for yourself for various future information also at any time you can
4:51
check what has recently been changed which is great but even more helpful
4:55
than that is the details of what has changed this visit which will pop up
4:59
when you save an exit from your UEFI BIOS next up we have azrock azrock
5:04
didn't have a quick start page but you can decide what page your UEFI will boot
5:08
into and that's quite handy and there's
5:11
a ufi guide wait what what the f is a
5:14
ufi guide well at first I thought it was going to be essentially Microsoft's
5:18
clippy but for ufi turns out I was wrong
5:21
the guide basically gives you a tour of asrock's ufi and tries to tell you how
5:26
things work for complete beginners it does contain some useful nuggets of
5:30
information but the implementation could have been a lot better it starts with
5:35
please remain seated and keep your hands away from the mouse and keyboard at all
5:39
times and I think to a degree they were actually serious other than pressing
5:44
escape to abort the guide doesn't have any real functionality no pause no
5:50
forward or back nothing so let's just
5:54
move on there's a favorite section on the main page it's a selectable button
5:58
that you can file things under not its own page like some other implementations
6:02
but to each their own and there's no real hotkey information list which I
6:07
found a little annoying you can find
6:10
hotkeys Associated by certain functions by highlighting them but that doesn't
6:14
really help you unless you memorize them especially since so many different
6:17
boards have different keys for different things other than F10 which is generally
6:22
being save and exit one unexpected feature is their dehumidifier function
6:28
that turns the computer on and spins the fan if it detects excessive humidity you
6:32
can check out asrock's video about this here overall asrock's ufi layout feels a
6:38
little outdated and unexceptional but that doesn't make it bad it gets the job
6:43
done without a bunch of extra junk in the way and that might be exactly what
6:47
you're looking for then we come to Gigabyte right off the top I have to say
6:50
this UEFI is aesthetically great overall
6:54
I'm happy to see that they included a startup guide which is essentially Quick
6:57
Settings right when you enter the buyo although it could maybe do with some
7:02
more useful selections considering system language system time security
7:07
load defaults and exit are over half the
7:10
buttons I think it would be more likely to get used if it had some more commonly
7:15
accessed settings and additionally you still have to click through these in
7:19
order to get to those settings anyways as they're just essentially large
7:24
shortcuts which kind of defeats the purpose of having a quick screen in my
7:29
my opinion but speaking of defeating the purpose and all that ranting aside you
7:34
can choose what menu type you want to boot into by clicking on Startup options
7:38
and changing the selected box now hold
7:41
up wait a minute you might be wondering what is Smart tweak mode and if there's
7:46
smart tweak mode what is classic Mode well before we went into startup options
7:51
did you notice those little gray lines on the left and right hand side yeah
7:56
those ones well they turn into arrows when you highlight them the left one
7:59
puts you into smart tweak mode and the right arrow puts you into classic Mode
8:04
classic Mode is pretty much exactly what you would expect it looks a little old
8:08
or should I say classic everything is right about where you'd expect it to be
8:12
there's no real surprises Frills or gimmicks but your hotkeys are nicely
8:17
laid out along the right hand side along with any additional extra information
8:20
about whatever you have currently selected it's nice enough but a little
8:24
boring so what exactly is smart tweak
8:28
mode smart tweak mode is essentially another skin for your ufi so yes there
8:32
are two different skin options for your ufi BIOS and a quick options UI holy
8:38
crap anyway smart tweak mode is the one I'd use it looks wonderfully modern and
8:43
it runs at up to 1080p on supported monitors and has a cool high-res graphic
8:48
in the background and nicely detailed status information wrapping around the
8:51
outside of your settings menus for some weird reason that goes away when you
8:56
select save an exit tab which is a little weird and your hotkey information
9:01
is on an unnecessarily scrolling bar along the bottom which should really
9:05
just stay put so you can actually read everything instead of waiting for it to
9:09
come back around but aside from some minor weirdness everything seems to be
9:13
fairly logically laid out with the major tabs being broken up into subtabs that
9:19
mostly remove the need to scroll by making it so that nearly everything is
9:23
above the fold which is a nice touch last but possibly not least we have MSI
9:29
for whatever reason when I first booted into MSI's ufi BIOS I didn't realize
9:33
that anything in the top Blue Ribbon was clickable it just looked like static
9:37
information at first that you would change elsewhere in the ufi eventually I
9:41
clued into the very obvious fact that you're able to interact with this area
9:45
in order to change your boot order OC Genie and XMP settings quickly and
9:50
easily which is a nice mix of adding a quick selection menu but also not adding
9:55
additional clicks for a user that just wants to actually get to what they
9:58
needed cuz they're more advanced moving on to the extremely large clickable
10:03
buttons we find that the settings OC M
10:07
Flash and OC profile areas are pretty standard Fair no surprises here but once
10:12
you get to hardware monitor and board Explorer things get a little bit more
10:16
interesting starting with hardware monitor you have manual control of all
10:20
your fans including four different levels of control while you have them in
10:24
smart fan mode and one level of control
10:27
when they're not in smart fan mode you also have the options to set all of your
10:31
fans to full speed set all of your fans to the default curve or cancel
10:35
everything out board explore is a cool little tool that will allow you to see a
10:39
graphical representation of what things are connected to your motherboard you
10:43
can see what fan headers are populated and how fast they're spinning what IO is
10:47
filled on the back of your board and what SATA headers are filled and the
10:51
corresponding drive that is connected to them amongst other things one gripe that
10:56
I did have with MSI's ufi was odd scrolling issues where I would try to
11:01
scroll down but instead of the selection going down it would keep jumping up to
11:06
where my mouse was or where I was scrolling making navigation by scrolling
11:10
rather frustrating and resulting in relying on my keyboard for everything
11:14
other than clicking on large buttons something that I was hoping we would
11:17
have moved on from this far into the UEFI game so kudos to you if you've made
11:22
it this far through the video the prize is the conclusion because For the First
11:27
Time in this series we need to cla a winner and a runner up some explanation
11:33
is needed for why we didn't do this before and that is because the answer
11:37
was well it depends on whatever ports
11:40
you need or what color bants you're wearing or whatever things are outside
11:45
of our control but for this one we wanted to assign an overall ranking for
11:50
non bugginess and general ease of use my top rated board was a Seuss with MSI as
11:55
a runner up both of these boards worked with every USB device we tested them
12:00
with both of these board had detailed and well implemented fan controls and
12:04
both of these boards had a well implemented quick selection menu
12:08
although I liked ASUS's a bit more and ASUS didn't have issues with mouse
12:13
scrolling which is why they took home the gold medal today but in the end mine
12:18
is not the only opinion so let's hear what you guys have to say about these
12:22
ufi BIOS implementations let me know what you like the most in the comments
12:25
down below or if you want to have me actually read them answer over on the
12:29
Forum all right guys while you're down below commenting on which ufi setup you
12:34
liked the most don't forget to like or dislike this video depending on the
12:38
color of your pants I guess favorite subscribe if you haven't for some reason
12:42
already done that and share this video if you want to help people pick a
12:45
motherboard over on the Forum comment there so that I actually read it if you
12:49
want get if you want to get rid of ads cuz there aren't any right now there
12:53
probably will be soon but there aren't any right now become a contributor also
12:57
we have something pretty cool coming for the contributor and other users of the
13:00
Forum fairly soon so stay tuned for that if you want to buy a shirt that isn't a
13:03
purple twitch shirt but has cooler stuff on it like keep on digging check out the
13:07
shirt description down below this video and thank you for watching I'll see you
13:10
next time oh my goodness that was almost
13:15
really bad this is not a shirt that you can buy lonus thought it was a shirt you
13:19
could buy it's not