$1,400 Wooden Keyboard vs. a $40 one
Linus Tech Tips
·Linus Tech Tips
·2018-05-06
·
1,516 words · ~7 min read
0:00
this may be the most expensive keyboard
0:03
we've ever tested individually addressable RGB keys
0:09
no cherry mx switches with custom keycaps
0:14
no Thunderbolt free pass-through with
0:18
triple OLED displays no it no it's got none of those things
0:24
it's the completely wooden hand-crafted
0:27
in japan keyboard from hakoa priced at
0:31
nearly 1400
0:34
us dollars but is it at all worth it
0:39
or does it get chopped by this 40 dollar chinese
0:43
keyboard that we bought on amazon
0:46
speaking of things that are worth it by the way tunnelbear tunnelbear thinks the
0:50
internet is better when everyone can openly access the same content so try
0:55
tunnelbear for free over at tunnelbear.com
0:58
LTT
1:09
available in either maple or walnut from responsibly managed forests we're going
1:14
to start with a look at the illustrious hakoa keyboard ki meaning both wood and
1:20
tree in japanese see what they did there simply put it's a work of art the 89
1:26
gently concaved keycaps are cut from a single panel of wood with their relative
1:31
position preserved such that the natural wood grain pattern is visible on the
1:35
finished board the keys contrast subtly with the
1:39
chassis which is one solid piece even on the back where they cared enough to
1:44
carve a recessed bevel so that the board is easy to pick up off the desk turning
1:49
now to the poop end of the stick we've got the 40
1:52
cooler tron other than the fact that this board is indeed made of wood its
1:56
appearance is not that similar to the hakoa key
2:02
okay hand carved sustainable bamboo
2:06
sure i guess but there's no cohesive color scheme and
2:10
the keys chassis pieces and the media keys have no consistency in the
2:15
direction of the wood grain then making matters worse at the top of
2:19
the board the wood motif is disrupted by an obnoxious cooler tron sticker and a
2:24
nearly useless power indicator led that
2:27
i would gladly trade in for caps and or
2:31
num lock lights something hakoa managed to include and in a way that actually
2:36
enhances the look of the board let's go back to the hakoa and look a
2:40
little closer the laser etched letters on the tree
2:43
board have amazingly sharp corners like they are they are perfect to the eye the
2:49
tactile guides are both elegant and functional and the keycaps are aligned
2:53
in perfectly straight rows one of the weakest points of the cheaper boards
2:58
looks on top of that poor key stabilization makes the spacing between
3:02
letters uneven assaulting your eyes and that impression is only made worse upon
3:06
closer inspection excusing even the corrugated look of the bamboo wood grain
3:12
the keycaps legend is etched with a degree of precision that i could
3:16
charitably describe as serviceable except for this internet explorer
3:20
looking key that won't be servicing me at all
3:23
when it comes to general build quality from a more keyboardy standpoint honestly neither of
3:28
them is the best we've seen i mean look at that flex hakoa
3:33
though at least to their credit all the keycaps are aligned and sit at the same
3:37
height by comparison check out coolertron's ragged afro and low rider
3:43
style question mark while we're at it
3:46
the edges are pretty rough the f9 key is randomly darker and the key guides
3:51
subjectively mind you are a little too subtle to be really useful
3:56
now some have complained that the legend on this one can be difficult to see
4:00
particularly in the dark but cooler tron claims that the symbols become easier to
4:05
read after two weeks of use presumably thanks to finger crud filling up the
4:09
grooves yummy so for build quality and style points
4:14
i'm giving it to hakoa it it even feels and smells way more
4:19
woody than the cooler tron which might sound inconsequential but it's actually
4:23
kind of the whole point here it's wood
4:26
all right then what about the practical aspects of this showdown the bamboo
4:32
board believe it or not is actually surprisingly decent to type on since
4:35
it's one of those memcanical keyboards meaning that the switches are membrane
4:39
but a small lip on the keycap gives the stroke a more tactile feel it's not as
4:45
loud as a set of cherry mx blues but it is louder than your typical membrane
4:49
board it's got a bit of a weird layout since it's a full 104 keyboard with a
4:54
numpad but then with compact navigation keys
4:57
but i might even go as far as to say that i like typing on it at least i
5:01
would if it weren't for that astonishingly heavy space bar
5:06
like this stupid thing takes the force of thor's hammer to press down
5:10
it's shorter than normal and it sits
5:14
left of center leading some typists to
5:17
accidentally hit the alt key instead alright then
5:21
but what about typing on a keyboard that is 35 times the price well to put it
5:26
plainly this membrane is mush
5:30
city people who aren't accustomed to mechanical boards might not notice but
5:36
those who are and who might be considering the hikoi
5:39
ki are barking up the wrong tree so to speak and this one's got a weird layout
5:45
too it's like japanese but with an english legend
5:49
which is great if you're japanese and you want to type in english but if
5:53
you're used to a north american keyboard like i am you will be annoyed by the
5:58
shortened enter and backspace keys you will have no use at all for the keys
6:03
that japanese speakers use to switch between their various alphabets and you
6:07
probably won't be a fan of the even stumpier space bar
6:12
though it should be noted that this one was actually easier to use because at
6:16
least it's centered so which one's better
6:19
well truthfully in spite of the awful space
6:23
bar the bambooler tron is probably the better typer so while you can get a real
6:29
mechanical keyboard at this price point the novelty makes it maybe a decent buy
6:35
especially since unlike the hakoa key
6:38
it's wireless then again we couldn't even slide the little door shut without
6:43
it breaking as for the keyboard i believe them when
6:47
they say that each individual unit is made by a japanese master craftsman in a
6:52
labor-intensive process at a rate of just
6:55
one per day unfortunately that craftsman
6:58
didn't spend any of that time on things that keyboard enthusiasts
7:02
actually care about to be clear no one here hated it i'm just a little
7:07
disappointed that someone could spend so much time making such a beautiful object
7:12
then charge a sizeable chunk of cash for it without even doing the requisite
7:16
market research to realize that for one thousand three hundred and eighty six
7:20
dollars we expect a braided cable
7:24
so then which one would i rather have in
7:28
my home office
7:31
honestly neither of them they're both kind of novelty items
7:36
though at least one of them is priced accordingly
7:40
i can't believe that we paid for this thing i feel like a total sap
7:46
that was awful but what's not awful is ting the mobile
7:50
carrier that's focused on customer service and customer satisfaction first
7:54
when you call ting you do not speak to a robot you get put through directly to a
7:58
person and you don't have to pay extra for that kind of service you pay only
8:03
for the air time that you use with the average ting bill only 23 bucks a month
8:08
per device and if you're stuck in a contract and switch to ting they'll even
8:12
cover 25 of your cancellation fee up to 75 bucks they've got new lower mobile
8:18
data rates data's now just 10 a gig beyond the first gig and every single
8:22
ting customer will be able to reap the benefits of this new change so head over
8:27
to Linus.ting.com and try out their savings
8:30
calculator it'll tell you how much you'll save then sign up at our link to
8:35
get 25 bucks in service credit or towards a new device we're going to have
8:38
that linked below so thanks for watching guys if this
8:41
video sucked you know what to do if it was awesome though get subscribed hit
8:45
that like button or check out the link to where to buy the stuff we featured
8:50
in the video description also linked in the description is our
8:53
merch door which has cool shirts like this one our community forum which you
8:57
should totally join and if you're still hanging around the video for this long
9:01
because you really think the hakoa key is that amazing maybe we'll have an ebay
9:05
link below too because i gotta get rid of this thing
9:09
fourteen hundred dollar keyboard