Philips Hue is a RIPOFF
Linus Tech Tips
·Linus Tech Tips
·2019-05-06
·
1,733 words · ~8 min read
0:00
so when i sat down to review the script for this video with Jake we debated the
0:04
title for a while and finally i asked him point blank
0:07
are phillips hue bulbs a ripoff and he
0:10
goes well i'd say they're making a pretty
0:14
good profit and isn't that pretty much the problem
0:17
with all of this smart home stuff by the time you got your brand name caseta
0:22
switches nest thermostat august lock hue bulbs you're five ten grand deep in this
0:28
stuff and every time i pull out a calculator and add it up i basically end
0:32
up with yeah screw it i'm gonna find another way
0:36
and find another way we did
0:53
no not that way in today's video we're gonna be looking at smart bulbs from a
0:58
relatively unknown company called yeelight that promised to be an
1:02
affordable alternative to philips hue and lifx
1:12
memory express is your go-to store for your electronic needs and services in
1:16
canada they're opening a new store in victoria bc and they're hiring for all
1:20
positions learn more at the link below first let's take a look at the
1:24
incumbents starting with the ultra popular phillips hue phillips was one of
1:29
the first players in the consumer smart lighting space back in 2012 when they
1:32
launched their system as an apple store exclusive the entire product stack
1:37
including their 800 lumen bulb makes use of the zigbee wireless standard a slow
1:43
but ultra low power mesh based network that connects compatible devices
1:47
together now it does require a hub to facilitate a connection to the outside
1:52
internet ow but the use of this tech allowed philips
1:56
to make
2:00
why why would you throw them
2:11
the use of this tech allowed philips to make devices like their tap wireless
2:15
button that can control your lights while only being powered by the kinetic
2:20
energy of pushing the buttons that is pretty damn cool
2:25
now a lot of people complain about the necessity of the hub
2:29
but even with the hubs pricing factored in the bulbs are still cheaper than our
2:34
next competitor and the added functionality seems like a worthwhile
2:38
compromise now let's take a look at the lifx ecosystem these guys are an
2:43
originally crowdfunded company one that actually shipped their product wow
2:48
and they also started out in 2012 with support for both iOS and Android unlike
2:54
hue at the time life x bulbs are wi-fi based meaning that no hub is required
2:59
but they do share some traits with the hue as they operate as a sort of mesh
3:04
with one master bulb connecting directly to your regular old Wi-Fi and the rest of
3:09
them connecting to each other via an 802.15.4
3:13
mesh network this technology makes lifx's bulbs the most efficient
3:18
and they also happen to be the brightest ones but that comes at a cost
3:23
even their minis will run you 45 bucks
3:26
each and their standard a19 bulbs weigh in at a whopping 60 dollars apiece
3:32
finally there's e-light a company we actually
3:36
don't know that much about and you might not have even heard of what we do know
3:41
is that they are affiliated in some way with xiaomi and that they have a metric
3:45
but ton of different products kind of like the philips hue ecosystem but we're
3:48
ignoring most of that because today's focus is on their smart bulbs and
3:52
specifically the RGB w1 it's similar to
3:56
the hue at 800 lumens but it costs just
3:59
shy of 18 right now on aliexpress with
4:03
no hub required that is less than half the cost of a hue bulb and less than a
4:08
third of the full-size lifx a saving that is huge all on its own and that
4:13
only increases as you purchase more and more bulbs
4:17
spec wise now it's a lot of the same with the only major differences being
4:21
the higher light output and the efficiency of the lightfx and the much
4:26
lower price of the e-light otherwise they all have the same rated life
4:30
expectancy the same warranty and the same mount type
4:34
let's talk setup then both the e-light and the live fx require an account to
4:38
control the lights at all by contrast hue works fine without an account but
4:43
only on your local network overall the setup process on all three
4:47
ecosystems is really easy with hue edging out a slight win here thanks to
4:51
its ability to add multiple lights at once and with the kit lights coming
4:55
pre-configured that's pretty nice as for the e lights we did experience
4:59
some weirdness where it would say setup failed almost every time but then after
5:04
backing out of that menu the light shows up and is fully functional it was kind
5:07
of like the setup wizard was timing out or something so if your lights still
5:11
don't show we'd recommend logging out and then back in that should fix the
5:14
issue with the light setup it's time to take a look at the apps
5:19
view features imo the most intuitive user experience
5:23
of the bunch almost all of the features are easy to access with both power and
5:28
brightness controls available on the main screen and setting up scenes and
5:32
schedules is a total breeze which also brings us to one of the app's biggest
5:36
shortcomings the lack of global scenes as well as the inaccessibility of them
5:41
scenes on the hue system are on a room by room basis meaning that if you wanted
5:45
to set both your kitchen and your living room to a specific scene you'd have to
5:50
click through two separate menus or issue two separate voice commands to
5:54
achieve that result lifx and yi light both have global scene
5:58
lighting speaking of which i guess let's move over to the lifx app
6:02
overall it's also very easy to use but i
6:06
feel like they kind of tried too hard to make the app unique and ended up
6:09
sacrificing some functionality in the process for example the color control
6:14
wheel has a super annoying design where you can only control it on one axis at a
6:19
time why are you trying to be special just
6:22
use a regular color wheel that you can just click on like everybody else i also
6:27
don't like the lack of brightness control on the main page
6:30
but i suspect this won't bother most people once they have their scenes set
6:34
up bringing us to the underdog elight their app
6:37
is a little less intuitive with some menus that are buried too deep and
6:41
several instances of unnecessary clicking but the overall functionality
6:46
is really solid with easy access to scenes and power and brightness controls
6:51
on the main pages it's also worth noting that the yeelight app has very powerful
6:56
scene control with customization of scenes available on a light by light
6:59
basis it can be pretty time consuming to set it up but it does give you a lot of
7:04
flexibility in return so considering the major flaw of the hue
7:08
app and the weird design choices of the lifx one we're going to give the win
7:11
here to yeelight for its powerful scene customization and no bs approach
7:16
last but not least we have to look at smart functionality
7:20
all three platforms have support for alexa google home yeti and if this than
7:25
that but apple users beware
7:29
as of shooting this video only lifx and hugh work with apple homekit now there
7:34
have been some rumblings of other xiaomi brands looking into homekit but at this
7:38
time the best you'll be able to find for your yeelight is some third-party home
7:44
bridge plug-in so if you're the hacky type yeah you could probably get it to
7:47
work but if you want something that just goes out of the box you'll need to pay
7:51
more for your lights or you could switch to Android
7:54
if you're an Android user any of these three are great choices
7:58
with if we had to pick a winner
8:01
i'd say for me the low cost of the ulights is
8:05
definitely going to be what finally gets me on the smart bulb train for my house
8:10
700 to do everything which i probably wouldn't do it's still a lot of money
8:14
but it's a lot less than two grand or
8:18
more with that said if you're looking for the
8:21
most efficient or the brightest lights lifx is the way to go and as for the hue
8:25
system well their saving grace is really
8:28
the accessories like motion sensors and
8:32
fancy buttons so if that kind of thing tickles your fancy then hue might be for
8:36
you can you believe we made it all this way in this video without making like a
8:40
joke something about these lights having like dragon energy or something
8:44
thermaltake's a500 aluminum mid tower case features a minimalistic approach
8:49
with a brushed aluminum surface for a clean uninterrupted look it's got hinged
8:53
tempered glass side panels on both sides of the case and fits radiators up to 420
8:58
millimeters at the front it supports up to four three and a half and two and a
9:02
half inch hard drives inside the left side panel or on top of the psu cover
9:06
and the i o panel includes a type c usb port so get yours today at the link in
9:10
the video description so thanks for watching guys if this video sucked you know what to do but if
9:14
it was awesome get subscribed hit the like button or check out the link to where to buy the stuff we featured at
9:18
the link in the video description also down there is our merch store which has cool shirts like this one and our
9:21
community forum which you should totally join there we have it there's a dragon
9:24
energy reference dragon oh wow his ear fell off
9:28
that wasn't my fault you drop everything
9:33
let caseta get the lights
9:37
honey did we get the lights downstairs
9:44
alexa turn on good night
9:47
okay