The dock that makes the iPad an iMac - Kensington StudioDock Review
Mac Address
·Mac Address
·2021-05-05
·
1,075 words · ~5 min read
0:01
- Remember that commercial Apple released a couple of years ago with the young girl
0:04
living her epic life with an iPad? At the end, while typing away on her smart keyboard,
0:08
her neighbor asks what she's doing on her computer, to which she responds,
0:12
"What's a computer?" Urgh! (relaxed upbeat music)
0:17
Oh, that's still hurts today. Man, how we hated that line.
0:20
It's interesting now because since then, Apple's been working very hard
0:23
to make the iPad more computer-like, with things like a USB-C port
0:27
and trackpad and mouse support. It leads us to this, the Kensington StudioDock.
0:35
It's the first accessory of its kind, and it asks the question,
0:38
"What if iPad was a desktop?" So, does it earn its $379 price tag?
0:44
And if it does, can the iPad even keep up? (upbeat music)
0:48
The Kensington StudioDock is one of the most comprehensive iPad docks out there.
0:52
It's designed for the ultimate Apple user. Compatible with the latest gen flat-edged USB type C iPads,
0:59
sporting two wireless charging pads, perfect for your iPhone and AirPods,
1:04
and supporting the Apple Watch, with this optional charging adapter too.
1:09
(soft upbeat music)
1:18
It plants your iPad firmly on the desk through a built-in hub that sports gigabit Ethernet,
1:23
four USB-3 ports, SD card reader,
1:26
headset jack, and an HDMI 2.0 output.
1:30
Design-wise it's all nicely integrated. I do love the fabric mat on the wireless chargers,
1:36
and how the iPad sits on the dock with minimal intrusion,
1:39
unlike other stands with their massive grabby grips on either side.
1:43
It rotates 90 degrees. This feels great.
1:47
And it tilts beyond 90. This feels okay.
1:50
There's no swivel or height adjust, but I didn't really miss that.
1:54
(relaxed upbeat music) But that doesn't mean I don't have gripes.
1:59
Firstly, it's nowhere near Apple standards of build quality.
2:02
The back is black plastic that creaks if you grab it,
2:07
and the placement of this power button is going to kill me.
2:11
Why isn't it in the center? The other sticking point is that
2:15
it's not that easy to place the iPad in here. It's supposed to slide into this USB-C plug
2:20
and stay secure with magnets, but there's also this grippy rubber pad and guardrails
2:24
which are great at holding things together once docked, but all these components are fighting each other
2:29
on the way in, to the extent that the experience
2:32
is just finicky rather than easy. You have to slide it in at a slight angle like this
2:39
and then just kind of mush it in. It's just not satisfying.
2:43
But, once it's in,
2:46
your iPad really well and truly does become a computer,
2:49
rotating between portrait for focused writing sessions
2:53
and landscape for multitasking. And if you do hook it up into an external monitor
2:57
with a mouse and keyboard, it really starts to feel like a desktop.
3:01
Well, almost. Here's the problem.
3:04
iPad OS really isn't a desktop operating system. External display support from the HDMI output
3:10
is only a mirror of the iPad interface, unless you're viewing photos or video.
3:14
Oh, and 4K resolution only works with the pros. This iPad Air maxes out at 1080p.
3:20
Regardless of resolution, you're going to get pillar boxing. And though the iPad on paper
3:25
is a four by three aspect ratio, don't expect it to fill those old monitors completely.
3:33
Now, how about going in the other direction and bringing your Mac screen to the iPad with Sidecar?
3:39
You can do that, but only wirelessly, so it's not the most responsive experience.
3:44
And unfortunately this USB-C port won't pass through.
3:48
That being said, I used the iPad and this dock for a whole week and it is remarkably capable.
3:54
I could easily write scripts, edit photos with Lightroom,
3:57
and when I was web browsing, I'd even forget I was on an iPad.
4:01
But the problem is that there are some times where it's very clearly not capable enough,
4:07
like when it needed to add a hyperlink to an email or multitask while on a video call
4:12
without having my camera turn off.
4:17
So then who is the StudioDock for?
4:21
This was the cause of much discussion in the office as we puzzled over this. (soft upbeat music)
4:24
The product bumpf shows a photographer person doing something with photos, but that's not enough.
4:29
So, here's the list I came up with.
4:32
Is it for realtors? Asked mine, said no.
4:37
Salesperson? Asked one I know, also said no.
4:40
Artists? Don't ask.
4:44
Point of sale? Spoiled children?
4:49
Writer? People with tiny desks?
4:54
(upbeat harp music) Yeah, people with tiny desks.
4:58
Especially considering how much new apartments have been shrinking these days.
5:02
So should you buy the Kensington StudioDock? At $379 for the small and 399 for the large model,
5:10
it's certainly a steep price. But the iPad has come a long way
5:13
since the days of half-baked accessibility mouse support and a lack of file server connectivity.
5:19
And if you buy all the elements of the StudioDock separately:
5:22
the hub, the wireless chargers, the stand, you'd be saving at least $115.
5:29
So that certainly would be a less expensive route, but it won't be as clean on your tiny baby hands desk.
5:36
(relaxed upbeat music)
5:41
If you like what the StudioDock offers, it's really the only game in town.
5:45
Those who are really committed to what the iPad has to offer and use it for everything
5:50
will find this quite perfect. But while I personally may feel the iPad is best
5:54
as a comfortable computer for the bed, living room and bathroom,
5:59
I can't help it feel that what Kensington is saying with the StudioDock is,
6:04
"Your move, Apple. You know what a computer is." It lays bare the iPad's capabilities and limitations.
6:10
Clearly Kensington thinks the iPad is ready to sit, elevated at the desk, ready for business or whatever.
6:19
Thank you for popping into this "Mac Address". I'm really curious who you think this iPad dock is for,
6:24
so please explain in the comments. There's something about the iPad conceptually
6:28
that gets people passionate for or against it. This StudioDock, eh, won't help that discussion.
6:34
(relaxed upbeat music)