GTX 680 Power, Temperatures and Acoustics Versus HD 7970 Reference & Non-Reference Linus Tech Tips
Linus Tech Tips
·Linus Tech Tips
·2012-05-07
·
1,381 words · ~6 min read
0:07
welcome to the power consumption heat and Acoustics oriented
0:13
segment of my sort of series of video
0:16
reviews on the GeForce GTX 680 uh this
0:21
one's from Galaxy although this is a reference board and I'll get into a
0:25
little bit more the advantages and disadvantages of our reference board
0:29
very very shortly so out of the cards that you guys see here so I've got the
0:34
GTX 680 I've also got a Radeon hd7970
0:38
which price-wise as well as Market positioning wise is its closest
0:42
competitor and what on Earth did he just
0:48
drop my cat is like dropping
0:53
things all right moving on closest
0:57
competitor in terms of positioning and and uh so we're going to see how these
1:01
two stack up head to-head both of these are reference cards and then there's one
1:05
card that I haven't tested yet so is not part of my graphs but I want to include
1:10
it uh less for the power consumption and
1:14
the here we go and the idle temperature
1:18
purposes and more for the load
1:22
temperature and load noise purpose because I mean the thing about any
1:26
launch card is it's always a reference card which means it's an NVIDIA designed
1:31
or an AMD designed card using a reference or AMD or NVIDIA designed
1:35
cooler with a reference AMD or NVIDIA designed PCB so the advantage of that of
1:41
that is that it's all validated by AMD or NVIDIA so that's good usually these
1:45
reference coolers tend towards the blower types of coolers which exhaust
1:49
air from the case which some people consider better whereas others prefer
1:53
the more open style of coolers which deliver significantly better cooling
1:57
performance for the GPU itself but do not necessarily keep the rest of your
2:02
system components as cool
2:07
um reference boards are pretty standard so you're not going to see a lot of
2:11
extra features like for example on um
2:15
you know highend SKS you sometimes see non-reference pcbs with more power
2:19
phases things like that better coolers so there's a non-reference card so at
2:23
launch we are pretty much stuck with reference boards I'm looking forward to
2:27
seeing GeForce GTX 680s with reference
2:30
designs but for now this is what we got and what the reason I want to compare
2:34
this non-reference 7970 is cu we're starting to see non-reference 797s now
2:39
and I want to look at what kind of an advantage it has in terms of especially
2:43
Acoustics as well as load temperatures compared to a reference card so let's do
2:47
charts and graphs first since that's everybody's favorite part of these
2:51
videos right so remember not including the sapphire uh dual x fan 7970 here
2:57
let's talk system idle temp to start with and my cat really needs to get out
3:03
of the way go on go away go away please
3:07
thank you all right here we go system idle
3:10
temperatures in degrees Cel so here I've got a wide variety of different cards
3:15
you can see that out of all of them the 6990 uh compared to its closest
3:20
competition in terms of performance which is the 680 and the 7970 as well as
3:25
the GTX 590 is by far the worst idle
3:28
temperatures but that kind of to be expected the 6990 is a bit of a beast
3:32
when it comes to uh noise as well as power consumption so I mean honestly so
3:37
is the 590 not as loud but definitely in terms of power consumption and heat
3:40
output the uh so the 680 comes in at 33°
3:44
honestly all of these are close enough and they're all quiet enough at idle
3:48
that none of it's really a concern now instead of using furmark for load
3:53
temperature testing which I have traditionally done in the past I am
3:57
using games now so I am recording temperatures during games and then I'm
4:01
tracking whatever was the highest temperature that was reached and I'm
4:04
going with that in fact you know what oh I guess I actually don't have to I don't
4:09
have to do the dual x 7970 because we can kind of extrapolate the results from
4:14
the dual x 7950 that I did use for my
4:17
testing I sort of forgot about that okay well either way I'll use this one for
4:21
the acoustic testing since I don't know if I have that 7950 on me right now so
4:26
reference boards all of these are reference cards the 7970 OC the 680 the
4:33
7970 non overclock 6990 570 580 590 and
4:36
GTX 680 non overclocked they all hover
4:40
around that 75 to 80° range although
4:43
they vary wildly in terms of Noise with the 6990 being by far the loudest check
4:47
out what you get by going with an aftermarket cooler you can drop 20 to
4:51
25° off of your load temperatures on your card we're talking real world
4:56
gaming load by the time you put it in a closed case you're probably going to gain another 3 to 5° but we're still
5:01
talking a very significant Improvement in performance of the cooler on your
5:06
card so that's something to bear in mind
5:10
um so that was with the 7950 OC from Sapphire which is using their dual x
5:14
cooler next we've got system Idol power draw so this is where this latest
5:18
generation of cards just obliterates the
5:21
previous generation cards check out these numbers 680 and
5:25
7970 consume up to a 100 or up to 50 or
5:30
60 watts less power than previous generation similarly performing cards
5:34
like the 6990 and the GTX 590 what that
5:37
means is basically the equivalent of not having a light bulb on at all times when
5:43
you have your PC on this is like having like just sort of like a random light
5:47
bulb on somewhere in your house at all times when your PC is idling in terms of
5:50
the extra power consumption and then at load the story gets even more dramatic I
5:55
mean check this out guys so the 6990 and the GTX X 590 are just
6:00
absolute power Hogs whereas these latest generation cards consume a trivial
6:05
amount I mean we're talking about 3% more power than a last generation 580
6:09
for the 680 but in spite of that the performance of this card is just worlds
6:15
better and I uhoh I just clicked something bad okay it's back uh is
6:20
world's better so the 680 in many scenarios is outperforming the GTX here
6:25
let's take Battlefield 3 for an example is outperforming the GTX 580 a factor of
6:30
more than double so in terms of the performance per watt it just just yeah
6:36
it just rocks I mean the 7970 is no slouch either although it does consume
6:40
more power under load versus the GTX 680
6:43
the 7950 consumes significantly less power and hopefully we'll see this
6:47
something similar from something like a GTX 670 or whatever the derivative is
6:51
going to be that comes out of it and I'm very very excited about
6:56
that system idle power draw in so yeah
6:59
we went through that so that's pretty much it so now let's just do some acoustic testing I'll give you guys some
7:03
idle and then gaming load uh reading so
7:07
my testing methodology as unscientific as this may be basically involves taking
7:11
my camera holding it a fixed distance away from the cards and then letting you
7:15
guys listen to it for a period of about 5
7:28
Seconds
7:53
honestly it's too bad that this particular 7970 has uh a significant
7:58
amount of coil wine it's based on a reference PCB while it does have a
8:02
reference cooler so uh you can't really tell how quiet the cooler is um I did
8:08
not have the same issue with the 7950 dual x uh that one was very very
8:14
quiet cuz it was using a sapphire designed PCB as opposed
8:19
to a reference one anyway don't forget
8:22
to subscribe yay